A difamação e a calúnia nas redes sociais

Defamation and Insult on Social Media

Defamation and insult are crimes against honour that are increasingly common on social media.

First of all, it is important to know the legal definition of these crimes in order to assess whether content about a particular person on social media may constitute a crime.

When do defamation and insult occur?

Defamation (difamação) occurs when someone, addressing a third party, attributes to another person – even in the form of a suspicion – a fact, or expresses a judgement about that person, that is offensive to his or her honour or reputation, or repeats such an attribution or judgement.

Insult (injúria) occurs when facts are attributed to someone, even in the form of a suspicion, or words offensive to his or her honour or reputation are addressed directly to that person.

The penalty is increased where the offence is committed through means or in circumstances that facilitate its dissemination or, in the case of the attribution of facts, where it is established that the offender knew the attribution to be false (Article 183 of the Criminal Code). This is what happens with social media posts. Under Brazilian law, falsely accusing someone of a crime constitutes the separate crime of calúnia.

When these crimes are committed on social media, what is the courts’ view?

A judgment of the Évora Court of Appeal held that:

“Posts of this kind on social media, made easier by being behind a screen, are rampant and are reposted rapidly, often leading to confusion between what is true, what is opinion and what is false, with often irreparable consequences for those targeted. Not everything is acceptable. An opinion about someone’s conduct is distinct from accusing a person of having committed unlawful acts.” (free translation)

A judgment of the Porto Court of Appeal held that:

“I – Defamation through the media is defamation carried out through a means of disseminating information to a large number of people, such as the press, television, radio, the internet, etc.
II – Whether the social network Facebook qualifies as a means of mass communication, for the purposes of the aggravation of the crime of defamation under Article 183(2) of the Criminal Code, does not depend on whether the offender posted the text and/or image with unrestricted access for any user on the profile wall; it depends not only on the restricted and personalised way in which the offender shares the content on the social network, but on the actual capacity of the content to spread.
III – Restricting a post to a group of thousands of friends on a more or less prominent Facebook profile tells us nothing about how widely the content is disseminated, given that there are newspapers and magazines with smaller circulations; everything depends on the actual possibility of the text and/or image being disseminated to a larger or smaller number of accessible recipients.”
(free translation)

And a judgment of the Lisbon Court of Appeal held that:

“… Rabindranath Capelo de Sousa teaches, in ‘O Direito Geral de Personalidade’, Coimbra, 1995, that ‘honour, in the broad sense, also includes good name and reputation, as expressions of society’s regard for the qualities that make each individual unique and for the other personal values acquired by the individual at moral, intellectual, sexual, family, professional or political level. It also encompasses simple decorum, as the projection of the individual’s behavioural values in social dealings. And it finally involves personal credit, as the social projection of the economic skills and capabilities developed by each person.’ For the subjective element of the crime of defamation to be met, specific intent is not required; general intent in any of its forms – direct, necessary or eventual – suffices. …
Article 183(1)(a) provides for an increased penalty whenever the offence is committed through means or circumstances that facilitate its dissemination. It must therefore be concluded, beyond doubt, that this provision applies. Indeed, given the reality of our community today, it should be accepted – as is already the case in several other countries (e.g. the United States and Brazil) – that the internet, and Facebook in particular, is in fact a means of mass communication. This is supported by the current number of heterogeneous and indeterminate users and by the way in which, within seconds, a post travels around the world through multiple shares – the ultimate expression of the ‘global village’. While most of the information shared on this social network will be mere trivialities and everyday events, it also serves as a channel for the dissemination of information. For these reasons, the aggravation provided for in Article 183(1)(a) of the Criminal Code is deemed to apply. There are no grounds excluding unlawfulness or guilt.”
(free translation)

What can we conclude from these decisions?

We can conclude that defamation and insult on social media carry a heavier penalty because of their capacity to disseminate and spread the offence.

Social media is not an appropriate place for offensive remarks disguised as “venting”, and any post that offends someone’s honour may lead to criminal liability for the person who disseminated the facts and/or information.

Some people also publish photographs of the offended person without authorisation in these posts. In that specific case, they may also be convicted of the crime of unlawful recordings and photographs.


All information is of a general nature and should not be regarded as professional legal advice. Each case is unique and must be assessed individually.

Our firm provides legal advice and assistance on this matter. If you have any questions, please contact us.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *